How Do Franchise Consultants Get Paid? A Consultant Explains

Most franchise consultants tell you their service is free. That is usually true, and it leaves the obvious question unanswered: how do franchise consultants get paid, and what does that mean for the advice you get? I am a franchise consultant, so I am answering a question about my own pay. I will give you the plain version, including the parts that are not in my favor, and the questions to ask anyone you work with, me included.

The Short Answer: The Franchisor Pays

In the standard model, the franchise consultant is paid by the franchisor, not by you. When a candidate the consultant introduced signs a franchise agreement, the franchisor pays the consultant a placement fee. You are never sent an invoice. If you do not buy a franchise, or you buy one the consultant did not introduce you to, the consultant is typically not paid at all.

This is the same basic structure a recruiter uses. The company doing the hiring pays the fee, and the candidate pays nothing. It is also why you will see nearly every consultant describe the service as free. That description is accurate. It just is not the whole picture.

How Franchise Consultants Get Paid in Practice

The details vary from one consultant to the next, and the specific amounts are rarely published. These are the parts that are common enough to understand before your first call:

• Placement fees are paid on signing. The fee is tied to a signed agreement with a franchisor the consultant works with. Exploring, comparing and walking away earn the consultant nothing.
• The fee can be flat or tied to the franchise’s cost. The FTC’s Consumer’s Guide to Buying a Franchise notes that some brokers earn a flat fee while others earn a commission linked to the cost of the franchise. Many arrangements are connected to the franchise fee, and the amount can differ from one brand to another.
• Most consultants work through a network. Many independent consultants belong to a franchise consulting organization that holds agreements with a portfolio of franchisors. I am a partner with The Franchise Consulting Company.
• The portfolio has limits. A consultant can only be paid by franchisors that have an agreement with them or their network. Brands outside that list may be excellent and will simply not come up in a typical search.

None of this is hidden or unusual, but it is rarely explained up front. A good consultant should be able to tell you how they are paid in a sentence or two, without getting uncomfortable.

What the Pay Model Means for You

The franchisor-paid model has real advantages. You get guidance at no cost, from someone who sees many brands and many candidates and knows which questions tend to separate a good fit from a bad one. A consultant who places people in businesses that fail does not last long, because franchisors notice and referrals dry up.

It also creates tensions you should know about. The FTC’s Consumer’s Guide points out three of them directly:

• Brokers often work for franchisors. The fee comes from the brand side, and a consultant is only paid if a sale is made.
• Commission tied to cost can push toward pricier options. If the fee scales with the size of the franchise, a more expensive brand can pay more.
• Some brokers represent any franchisor willing to pay. That can include brands that are struggling.

My own position is simple. Franchisors pay a placement fee, so I have no interest in any particular brand. What I care about is the right fit for you and for the franchisor, because a placement that goes wrong is bad for everyone, including me. But you should not take that on trust from me or anyone else. You should test it.

Questions to Ask Any Franchise Consultant About Pay

These come partly from the FTC’s guidance and partly from what I would want to know if I were on your side of the table. Ask them on the first call:

• Who pays you, and how is the payment calculated?
• Does your fee differ from one brand to another?
• How many franchisors do you work with, and how are they selected?
• How many brands has your network turned down recently, and why?
• Would you be paid if I bought this specific brand?
• Will you tell me if I should not buy a franchise at all?
• Have you ever owned or run a business yourself?

A consultant who answers these clearly is worth your time. A consultant who changes the subject has told you something too.

Consultant, Broker or the Brand’s Own Sales Team?

It helps to know who else in the process is paid by the franchisor. The franchise development representative you speak to at a brand works for that brand. Their job is to sell that one franchise, and their compensation usually reflects it. There is nothing wrong with that, but their view of the decision starts and ends with their own system.

A consultant or broker is also paid by the franchisor, but only after comparing options across several brands with you. That comparison is the whole value of the service. If a consultant presents only one brand, or keeps steering back to the same one no matter what you say about your budget and goals, the comparison is not really happening.

Red Flags That the Pay Model Is Driving the Advice

Most consultants are honest, but the incentive is real, so watch for signs it is shaping what you hear:

• They cannot or will not explain how they are paid
• The brands they present sit at or above the top of the budget you gave them
• They discourage you from calling franchisees outside the list they provide
• They push you to sign before you have had time with the FDD and a franchise attorney
• They never raise the possibility that a franchise is not right for you

Any one of these is worth a direct question. Two or more is a reason to get a second opinion before you go further.

How to Check What You Are Told

You do not have to rely on the consultant’s word. The franchise process gives you several ways to verify things for yourself:

• Call franchisees directly. Item 20 of the FDD lists current and former franchisees. Call people beyond the short list the franchisor or the consultant suggests. My guide to franchisee validation calls covers what to ask.
• Read the FDD yourself. The fees, the initial investment, any financial performance representation in Item 19 and the unit turnover in Item 20 are all there. Start with how to read an FDD.
• Use the waiting time. You must receive the FDD at least 14 days before you sign a binding agreement or pay the franchisor any money. Nobody, consultant included, should be rushing you through that window.
• Have a franchise attorney review the FDD. Always use a franchise attorney, not a general business attorney, before you sign.

Is a Free Franchise Consultant Worth It?

For most first-time buyers, yes, as long as you understand the pay model and treat the consultant as one input rather than the final word. The value is in the process: narrowing the field to brands that fit your budget, your runway and the way you want to work, then helping you do the diligence properly. The FTC also suggests asking yourself whether you need a broker at all, and some buyers who already know their industry do fine on their own.

If you have already found a brand and want someone outside that sale to look at it, a free franchise second opinion is a different and narrower service, and it is often the better fit.

Keep Reading

• What a franchise consultant does, step by step
• Franchise consultant near me: does local matter?
• Get a free franchise second opinion before you buy

Ready to Talk It Through?

Ask me any of the questions above on the first call. No cost, no pressure and no obligation to look at a single brand. If the right answer is that a franchise is not the right move for you right now, you will hear that too. Book a free call here.

Frequently Asked Questions